Home / Compare / Manual check with MXToolbox / DMARC analysers
Comparison · updated 11 September 2026

MailMedic vs checking SPF, DKIM and DMARC by hand

There is no other Shopify app that checks email authentication the way MailMedic does, so the honest comparison is with the manual route: MXToolbox, a DMARC analyser and Shopify's own help pages. That route works. It also takes an hour, requires you to know what “v=spf1 include:shops.shopify.com” means, and tells you nothing about whether your Shopify sender domain is aligned. Here is what MailMedic does instead.

MailMedic vs Manual check with MXToolbox / DMARC analysers

MailMedicManual check with MXToolbox / DMARC analysers
PriceFree for one domain · Pro $1.99/mo for more domainsFree web tools (paid tiers for monitoring)
FreeFull check of one domain, plain-language fixesIndividual record lookups
What is checkedSPF, DKIM, DMARC, Shopify sender alignment, MX, in one reportOne record per lookup; you interpret the result
FixesExact DNS record to add, per provider, copy-pasteGeneric guidance, not Shopify-specific
MonitoringWeekly re-checks with alerts (Pro)Paid tiers on some tools
AccessRead-only: never touches DNS or the storePublic DNS only
App Store ratingNew (launched Aug 2026)
Built for Shopify badgeNot yet

Competitor data from the tools' public pages, last checked 11 September 2026. Manual check with MXToolbox / DMARC analysers is a trademark of various free web tools; Liūto Apps is not affiliated. MailMedic rating reflects a 2026 launch.

Why merchants use MailMedic

  • One report for SPF, DKIM, DMARC, MX and Shopify sender alignment, with one health score.
  • The exact record to add, worded for your DNS provider, copy-paste ready.
  • Plain-language explanation of each problem — no jargon, no guessing.
  • Weekly re-checks (Pro) that alert you when a record breaks after a DNS change.

Switching in 10 minutes

  1. Install MailMedic and run the free check on your sending domain.
  2. Add the records it lists at your domain provider — SPF, DKIM CNAMEs, DMARC — copy-paste.
  3. Re-run the check after DNS propagates. Turn on weekly monitoring with Pro if you manage more than one domain.

Questions

Does MailMedic change my DNS?

No. It only reads public records and Shopify's sender configuration. You make the change at your domain provider, with the record MailMedic gives you.

I bought my domain through Shopify — do I need this?

Shopify-managed domains are usually configured automatically. Run the free check anyway; it takes ten seconds and confirms it.

Why is Pro only $1.99?

The check is cheap to run. Pro exists for agencies and multi-store owners who want several domains monitored.

Other comparisons

Ready to switch?

Free for one domain. Read-only, nothing to break.

Learn moreAdd MailMedic to Shopify